Impossible Monsters

February 1, 2024

Taylor's debut, The Interest, was shortlisted for the Orwell Prize for Political Writing. He returns with a dinosaur book, this one illuminating the ways their discovery and resulting bestiary shifted religious authority, introducing questions that many raced to solved and others sought to quash. The book follows Charles Darwin, Mary Anning, and others as they changed the world. Prepub Alert.

Copyright 2023 Library Journal

Copyright 2024 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

April 15, 2024
A remarkable look at how sweeping social changes can come from strange and small beginnings. Anyone who thinks that the culture wars of contemporary times are being fought with unprecedented ferocity should take a look at this book, "a history of the geologists, paleontologists, and biologists who...discovered dinosaurs, expanded our knowledge of the earliest ages of Earth, and transformed our understanding of humankind's descent." Taylor, a well-regarded historian and author of The Interest, focuses on Britain in the 19th century and how the absolutes of fundamentalist religion were upended by discoveries of dinosaur bones and other fossilized remains. Until that time, the authority of the church was largely unchallenged. Consequently, the early-18th-century discovery of ancient bones of unknown creatures raised serious questions. At this time, Britain was undergoing a development boom, and the construction of new mines and railways soon revealed more bones. As the evidence of prehistoric animals continued to mount, the religious authorities found themselves on the defensive. There were many efforts to reconcile the emerging sciences with biblical history, but clearly there was no going back, despite fierce debate at every level. The speed of all this is striking: Essentially, within two generations, the basis of society shifted from religious certainty to scientific inquiry. "Few if any transformations in intellectual history have been more profound," Taylor concludes. It's telling that when Darwin, who had once been pilloried as a crank and a fraud, died in 1882, he was buried with honors in Westminster Abbey. Taylor ably conveys the ferment of the time, and he does so with respect to all concerned. This is an intriguing and accessible book, featuring many useful insights into how one age ended and another began. With careful research, Taylor unravels how the discovery of the past pointed the way toward a new future.

COPYRIGHT(2024) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

July 1, 2024
This insightful account describes how fresh scrutiny of ever-increasing, surprisingly diverse fossils, increased geological understanding, and Darwin's Origin of the Species, as well as other emerging theories regarding evolution, roiled religious doctrine and long-held scientific thinking during the 1800s. As recently as 200 years ago, most educated individuals in western Europe and the U.S. believed that the world began in 4004 BCE, and that excavated animal skeletons belonged to unfortunate creatures that missed Noah's ark. As British historian Taylor describes how science-based secularism impacted ingrained religious beliefs, he sets nuanced scenes that provide ample context and creates satisfying profiles of major players, from specimen hunters to naturalists to theologians. He shows how the arc of public opinion, fueled by breathlessly documented tales of voyages to exotic locales, major natural phenomena exhibitions, and media reports of dinosaur wars in the American west gradually shifted from ridicule and dismissiveness to accepted fact and even mania-like popularity. Taylor is an engaging narrator, and his thoroughly documented offering is convincing, and should prove satisfying to a wide audience.

COPYRIGHT(2024) Booklist, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.